What a demand letter does
A demand letter is the formal last request before you sue. It tells the other side exactly how much they owe, why, and the date it must be paid, and that you’ll file in small claims court if it isn’t. Many people pay once they see it in writing, because a court case costs them more than the debt.
If they don’t, the letter is still useful: small claims judges often ask whether you asked for the money in writing before filing, and your letter plus the certified mail receipt answers that.
What to put in it
Leave out threats of police or criminal charges. Tying a criminal threat to a demand for money can itself be illegal, so Sternly never writes one into a demand letter; the only consequence it names is court.
- Who you are and what the money is for: the job, the loan, the item, the damage.
- The exact amount and when it was due.
- What you’ve already done to collect (emails, calls, invoices).
- A clear deadline, usually 10 to 14 days.
- The consequence: a small claims case for the amount plus court costs.
- How they can pay you.
After you send it
- Mail it by Certified Mail with a Return Receipt and keep a copy.
- Wait until the deadline. If they offer a payment plan, get it in writing.
- If nothing arrives, file in small claims court in the county where they live or where the deal happened. Every state sets its own dollar limit, so check your court’s website.
- Bring the letter, the receipt and your invoices or messages to court.
What it costs elsewhere
Prices from each company’s own page, checked November 21, 2026.
Questions
Do I need a lawyer to send a demand letter?+
No. You can send it in your own name, and small claims court is designed for people without lawyers. Sternly writes the letter from your facts for $19.99.
How long should I give them to pay?+
Ten to fourteen days is common and reasonable. Sternly defaults to 14 days and lets you choose 7 to 30.
Can I charge interest or late fees?+
Only if your agreement or your state’s law allows it. Sternly’s letter asks the court for “any interest the law allows” instead of inventing a number.
What if they still don’t pay?+
File a small claims case. Your demand letter shows the judge you tried to settle first, which many courts expect.
Can I use it for a security deposit?+
Yes, but use Sternly’s security deposit demand letter: it cites your state’s deposit law and deadline in the 15 states we cover.